The Grotto BK Serves Up a Taste of Jamaica With a Fresh New Look

There's something about the smell of food cooking over a charcoal grill that immediately reminds me of Jamaica. It's a distinctive aroma, one that brings back memories and the unmistakable flavors of Jamaican cooking. So, when I stepped inside The Grotto BK in Brooklyn, and that familiar smoky aroma drifted through the dining room, I already had a good feeling about what was to come.

ChefAmelChef Amelda Josephine Smith, also known as "Chef Mommy" (Contributed photo)Located at 321 Nostrand Avenue in Brooklyn's Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood, The Grotto BK has recently reopened following a year-long structural overhaul that has given the family-run Jamaican restaurant a fresh, contemporary look without losing the cultural identity at the heart of its food.

The renovations include a redesigned interior, a fully rebuilt and expanded kitchen, a new patio, and a new bar. There's seating for 22 guests in the restaurant's front dining area, another 40 on the patio, and space for 40 more in the new bar area.

The restaurant strikes a balance between modern Brooklyn sophistication and the warmth of a Caribbean gathering place. The interior is sleek and stylish, but the atmosphere remains welcoming and relaxed. Great music filled the space throughout my visit, and as the evening progressed, the restaurant grew noticeably busier, bringing an increasingly lively energy to the dining room.

Behind The Grotto BK is a mother-daughter team with deep Jamaican roots. Chef Amelda Josephine Smith, affectionately known as "Chef Mommy," serves as co-owner and culinary director, while her daughter, Amelda Ashley Hazle, is co-owner and managing director.

Their vision is to preserve the flavors and traditions of Jamaican home cooking while presenting them in an elevated dining environment. It's an approach that works particularly well because, for all its contemporary touches, the food remains unmistakably Jamaican.

My experience was made even better by Allison, my server for the evening. She was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and helpful throughout my visit. Good food is obviously essential to a restaurant experience, but attentive, personable service can make an evening that much more enjoyable, and Allison certainly delivered.

Starting Things Off RightchefackeeAckee Tostones (Photo by Brandon Webley)

I began my evening with a cucumber mint mojito, accompanied by a glass of water infused with mint, cucumber, and lemon.

The mojito was excellent. Cool, refreshing, and packed with the bright flavors of cucumber and mint, it was an enjoyable way to start the meal. And while those refreshing flavors certainly stood out, there was no mistaking the presence of white rum!

It felt like a distinctly Jamaican take on the classic Cuban cocktail, combining the freshness you'd expect from a mojito with a welcome Caribbean kick.

For my appetizer, I decided to try one of the restaurant's newest creations: ackee tostones.

As someone familiar with ackee and saltfish, Jamaica's national dish, I was particularly interested in seeing how the kitchen would reinterpret such a beloved classic.

The dish arrived with three tostones, each topped with a serving of ackee and saltfish. It was an interesting combination, bringing together the familiar savory flavors of ackee and saltfish with the fried plantain base.

What I appreciated most was that the dish offered a different way to enjoy something so familiar. The ackee and saltfish remained the star of the show, while the tostones added a new dimension to the presentation and overall experience. It was a creative, satisfying appetizer and a promising start to the meal.

chefcurryClassic Jamaican Curry Goat (Photo by Brandon Webley)The Star of the Show

For my main courses, I sampled two dishes: the curry goat, a Jamaican classic, and the braised oxtail pasta, another new addition to The Grotto BK's menu.

I'll start with the curry goat.

Few dishes are as synonymous with Jamaican cooking as a well-prepared curry goat, and it's one of those meals where the quality of the meat and the seasoning can make all the difference.

The Grotto's version certainly delivered on both fronts. The meat was of excellent quality, and the curry was full of that rich, satisfying flavor that makes the dish such a favorite. It came with a generous helping of rice and peas and cabbage, making for a hearty and satisfying meal.

But as good as the curry goat was, I have to give the evening's top honors to the braised oxtail pasta.

This dish was absolutely fantastic.

The pasta was rich, creamy, and spicy, with hints of Scotch bonnet pepper adding a distinctly Jamaican touch. The sauce had a wonderful depth of flavor, and the spice gave the dish just the right amount of excitement.

The oxtail was braised and wonderfully savory, the meat brought its own richness to the plate. The oxtail was delicious on its own, and the creamy, spicy pasta could easily have stood as a dish by itself. But together? They were exceptional.

There's something incredibly satisfying about combining two elements that are already delicious individually and discovering that they taste even better together. It was easily my favorite dish of the evening and the one I'd be most excited to order again.

Saving Room for Something SweetCHEFpastaOxtail Pasta (Photo by Brandon Webley)

By the time dessert rolled around, I'd already eaten more than enough food to call the evening a success. But when you're visiting a restaurant for a review, passing up dessert would almost feel like leaving a job unfinished.

I ordered Chef Mommy's Carrot Cake: served warm, with a drizzle of caramel and a dusting of powdered sugar, the cake was incredibly satisfying.

Every bite had that wonderfully comforting quality you hope for in a homemade dessert. The texture was especially memorable: soft, delicate, and perfectly cakey without being dry or heavy.

Between the generous portions I'd already enjoyed and the warm sweetness of the carrot cake, I was about ready to find somewhere comfortable to take a nap!

If the oxtail pasta was the star of the main course, the carrot cake was certainly a worthy finale.

More Than Just a New Look

Although I only sampled a selection of the menu, The Grotto BK has plenty more to offer.

Other new additions include Bashment Branzino, prepared in a variety of Jamaican styles, while longtime favorites such as jerk chicken, jerk pork, signature oxtail, and hot honey lamb chops remain on the menu.

The restaurant is also introducing a Bar Bites menu, with offerings such as Grotto Wings, oxtail-loaded fries, a Grotto Smashburger, fried jerk chicken and jerk pulled pork sandwiches, and a trio of tacos featuring shrimp, jerk chicken, and escovitch fish.

chefMommChef Mommy's Carrot Cake (Photo by Brandon Webley)It's an interesting mix of traditional Jamaican flavors and more contemporary casual dining options, reflecting the restaurant's broader approach to Caribbean cuisine.

General manager Thomas Meyer is also part of the team helping bring this new chapter of The Grotto BK to life.

Jamaican food is more than just a collection of dishes. It's tied to family, memories, and the experience of gathering around a table to enjoy a good meal.

The Grotto BK has plenty to offer diners looking for Caribbean flavors in the heart of Brooklyn. And as Chef Mommy told me on my way out "you don't need a plane ticket to get a taste of Jamaica!"

Just make sure you save room for the oxtail pasta.

And the carrot cake.

Trust me, you'll want both.